Car-sharing is great for a quick errand, a rental is often better for a full day, a weekend or a week. How to choose between the two in Montréal.

Montréal has plenty of ways to get around without owning a car: the metro, buses, bikes, car-sharing services and traditional car rental. Car-sharing and rental are often compared, but they are built for different trips. One is perfect for a two-hour errand, the other usually wins for a full day, a weekend away or a week of driving. Here is how to choose.

In short

  • Car-sharing is generally billed by time and distance, sometimes with a membership plan. It shines for short, local trips.
  • Car rental is billed by the day, week or month, with a kilometre allowance or unlimited mileage depending on the vehicle. It shines for longer trips.
  • For a weekend away, a move or a family trip, rental usually gives you more space, more predictability and a vehicle that is yours for the whole period.

How car-sharing works

With a car-sharing service such as Communauto, you sign up, get your account approved and then book a car parked at a station near you, or pick up a free-floating car in a designated zone. You are generally billed for the time you use and the distance you drive, and some plans include a membership fee in exchange for lower rates. Larger vehicles, such as family cars or SUVs, often cost more than a compact. Peer-to-peer platforms such as Turo work differently again: you rent a car from a private owner.

How car rental works

With a rental, you book a specific vehicle for a set period: a day, a weekend, a week or a month. You pick it up at a counter, it stays with you for the whole period, and you return it at the agreed time. At U-Lease, you can rent from age 18, and a credit card is not required: the deposit can be paid by debit, cash or Interac e-Transfer.

Side-by-side comparison

  Car-sharing Car rental
Best for Short local trips and errands Full days, weekends, weeks or months
Billing Generally by time and distance, sometimes with a membership By the day, week or month, with a kilometre allowance or unlimited mileage depending on the vehicle
Vehicle choice Whatever is available near you You choose the category: sedan, SUV, 7-seat minivan or cargo van
Availability Depends on what is free near you at that moment Booked in advance for your dates
Space Varies by service; larger vehicles often cost more Up to 7 seats, or a cargo van for a move

When car-sharing makes more sense

  • You need a car for one or two hours, close to home.
  • You already have a membership and a station nearby.
  • You drive only a few kilometres.

When renting makes more sense

  • A full day or more. A day trip, a weekend in the Laurentians or the holidays with family.
  • A long distance. Rentals come with a daily kilometre allowance, and our cargo vans include unlimited mileage.
  • More space. A SUV for winter, a 7-seat minivan for the family or a cargo van for a move.
  • A month or more. When you need a car while your own is in the shop or while you settle in, a monthly rental is often simpler.
  • No credit card. Many newcomers and students do not have one yet. At U-Lease, it is not required.

Winter tip

In Québec, winter tires are mandatory from December 1 to March 15, including on rental vehicles, according to the Québec government. Whatever option you choose, the car you drive in winter has to be equipped.

Do the math for your trip

The best way to choose is to compare your real trip. Write down how many hours or days you need the car and roughly how many kilometres you will drive, then compare the total cost of each option. For anything longer than a day, check the price of a rental for your exact dates on our booking page.

Not driving at all? Our guide to getting around Montréal without a car covers public transit and other options.

Frequently asked questions

Can I rent a car without a credit card in Montréal?

Yes, at U-Lease. The deposit can be paid by debit, cash or Interac e-Transfer. Read more about renting without a credit card.

Can I rent at 18?

Yes. U-Lease rents to drivers from age 18, with no young driver surcharge.

How do I know which option is cheaper?

Compare the total for your exact trip. Our booking page shows the price for your dates, whether you need the car for a day, a week or a month.

Need a car for more than a few hours?

Daily, weekly and monthly rentals, from age 18, no credit card required.

Book now 1 (866) 725-2131